Welcome to Mama Renie’s Pizza
Nestled in the heart of Nelsonville, Mama Renie’s Pizza embodies the charm of a classic pizzeria. With its quaint décor and welcoming staff, it invites both locals and visitors to indulge in hearty pizzas and generous salads. Diners rave about the perfectly cooked crusts and the abundance of toppings, evoking nostalgia for small-town pizza shops. Whether savoring a slice or enjoying a robust sub, each dish reflects a commitment to quality and flavor. The warm ambiance, accentuated by good music and friendly service, makes Mama Renie’s a delightful spot for families and groups seeking comfort in every bite.
Mama Renie’s Pizza: Reviews & Ratings
Pizza was great! Perfectly cooked, plenty of toppings and that staff that waited on us was super nice. Will definitely order again our next trip!
First time being here in several years. Pizza is just ok, it lacks decent flavor in its sauce. The crust had a nice crunch to it but not the best quality overall. We also had a salad that was great and lived up to the jumbo that the menu says. Our son had a Ham and Cheese sub and he seemed to like it well. The interior is quaint and the employees wiped the table often while we were there. All the employees were nice and appreciative of our business but I don't think we will return often based on the flavors.
The lady working at restaurant was very welcoming. She made some awesome garlic bread for our salad while we waited for the pizza. Salad was a huge portion for the price. Pizza was great. All the food was really good and reminded me of the small town pizza shops that we all love.
Great subs! Great pizza! Great staff! Good music too! They use very creative and unique ways to advertise their business.
We order two pizzas. One was plain cheese and the other had pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms and extra cheese. They both were delicious. The restaurant is a very cute older building. Would definitely recommend.
Great pizza! Fresh, hot, and just what we needed on a rainy afternoon. We ordered a large meat pizza for 3 of us. Took home leftovers for lunch. Good choice.
This was a very cute little place. The buffalo chicken pizza was delicious, as well as the garlic bread. Give this place a shot if you are ever near hocking hills!
A big surprise to find this pizza place while on an escape from daily life in the city. It's a smaller shop with many options. You can choose ultra thin, thin, thick or extra thick crust. You and add any seasoning to the crust and they offer many toppings. The pizza was very good served right on time. If your in the area and wanting pizza stop in and order. You won't be disappointed
We recently moved here and were so happy to find this amazing pizza...better than anything we had from the Polaris area! The crust is perfection and the toppings are generous! Great pizza!!!
Location
-
23 Public Sq Nelsonville, OH 45764 Hotline: (740) 753-2116
Welcome to Mama Renie’s Pizza, a charming eatery nestled in the heart of Nelsonville, Ohio. This delightful pizza spot combines a cozy ambiance with homemade flavors, offering a slice of pizza heaven that will keep you coming back for more.
At Mama Renie’s Pizza, you can indulge in a variety of culinary delights. Known for their perfectly cooked pizzas, the menu caters to a range of tastes with generous toppings that are sure to please. Whether you're in the mood for a classic cheese slice or something more adventurous, the creativity here shines through. And let's not forget the impressive garlic bread! Made fresh and served warm, it’s an excellent companion to your salad while you await your main course.
- Location: Conveniently situated at 23 Public Sq, Nelsonville, they offer outdoor seating to enjoy nice weather and a classic small-town vibe.
- Family-friendly: It’s a perfect spot for families, complete with good options for kids and accommodating staff.
- Versatile dining options: Whether you're looking to dine in, take out, or enjoy delivery, Mama Renie’s has you covered.
- Great atmosphere: With moderate noise levels and a welcoming interior, the restaurant provides a cozy setting for groups or intimate meals alike.
- Catering & reservations: Planning a party? They also cater, ensuring your large gatherings are just as delicious!
The staff at Mama Renie’s Pizza adds to the warm, welcoming experience. Many patrons, like Jake J. and Brian H., have remarked on the friendly service they received. It's reassuring to dine at a place where employees genuinely appreciate your business. The overall positive atmosphere is enhanced by the tasteful choice of music and rustic decor that evokes nostalgia.
While the flavors of the pizza may have received mixed feedback, the sense of community and the charm of this quaint establishment shine through. Michael T. mentioned that while the pizza's sauce could use a bit more kick, the salads are sizable and well-prepared, proving that there's something for everyone here.
In a nutshell, Mama Renie’s Pizza may just be your next favorite neighborhood pizzeria. From delicious subs to hearty salads and, of course, pizza with plenty of character, it’s all about comfort food in a setting that feels like home. Make your way to 23 Public Sq, or call (740) 753-2116 to place your order or reserve a table. Discover the local flavors and heartwarming service that Mama Renie’s has to offer—you'll be glad you did!
